Pages

Showing posts with label Fiqh: 7 ash-Sharh al-Mumti (Nullifiers of Wudhoo). Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fiqh: 7 ash-Sharh al-Mumti (Nullifiers of Wudhoo). Show all posts

Thursday, March 03, 2016

Chapter: Nullifiers of Wudhoo - Tawaaf (Part 13)

-Tawaaf without Wudhoo is invalid. ‘Uthaymeen explains that it is not permissible to perform Tawaaf without Wudhoo, irrespective of whether it is part of the pilgrimage or not – such a person performing a voluntary Tawaaf.

The evidence for this includes the following:

-When the the Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him] wanted to perform Tawaaf he would make Wudhoo. [Reported by al-Bukhaaree (1614) and Muslim (1235)].

-The Hadeeth of Safiyyah [may Allaah be Pleased with her] who said that she started her menses so she couldn’t perform her Farewell Tawaaf (at-Tawaaf al-Wadaa) so the Prophet said, “Is she holding us back from travelling?” [Reported by al-Bukhaaree (1757) and Muslim (1211)].

-The Prophet said, “Tawaaf around the House is Salaat, except that Allaah has Permitted in it normal speech, so do not speak except that which is good.” [Reported by at-Tirmidhee (960), Ibn Khuzaymah (2739), Ibn Hibban (3836) and others. Some said this narration is Mawqoof to Ibn Abbaas (such as an-Nasaa’ee, al-Bayhaqee, Ibn as-Salaah, al-Muntharee and an-Nawawee) and others said it is Marfoo’ (Ibn as-Sakan, Ibn Khuzaymah, Ibn Hibban, al-Haakim and Ibn Hajar). See: at-Talkhees al-Habeer (174)].

-Some of the scholars quoted the Aayah, “purify My House (the Ka'bah at Makkah) for those who are circumambulating it” [al-Baqarah 2:125]

The point here is that the house must be purified at all times.
This is the opinion of the majority.

There are others who stated that Wudhoo is not a condition to perform Tawaaf, and it is permissible for a person who doesn’t have Wudhoo to perform Tawaaf but maintaining that having Wudhoo would be better. This is the opinion of the Hanafees and Ibn Taymiyyah.

There evidences are as follows:

-There is no explicit proof to suggest one needs Wudhoo.
-It entails a great deal of difficulty, especially during peak seasons.

-The Hadeeth of the Prophet making Wudhoo before Tawaaf is an action of the Prophet, and this doesn’t necessitate an obligation. Rather, it can be interpreted that it is better to have Wudhoo, but not an obligation.

-As for the Hadeeth of the Safiyyah then she was menstruating and this a major form of impurity, so there is no analogy between this and a minor form of impurity which is Wudhoo.

-Those with all forms of major impurity cannot enter the masjid, but the opposite is true with minor forms. All the scholars are agreed that a person with minor forms of impurity can stay in the Masjid, so there is no proof in the Hadeeth of Safiyyah.

-As for the Hadeeth, “Tawaaf around the House is Salaat…” then there are two answers to this:

                -It is the statement of Ibn Abbaas and not a Hadeeth, thus there is no ruling.

-It is contradictory – if we say it is precisely like Salaat, then there would be Takbeer, Tasleem, Rukoo and Sujood in the Tawaaf. For this reason, some of the scholars have stated the Hadeeth is either weak or not a statement of the Prophet but a statement of Ibn Abbas instead.

NOTE: there is a principle in Fiqh, “If something is generalized but then an exception is made then everything is like it except the exception that is made” (الاستثناء معيار العموم).
So for example, Salaat and Tawaaf have been compared but speaking has been permitted, therefore according to this principle the Tawaaf should still have Rukoo, Sujood and other pillars of the Salaat, but it doesn’t. This is the point here.

-As for the Aayah, then this is connected to what we mentioned before – staying in the Masjid is permitted even if a person has minor impurities but it is not permitted to stay in the Masjid for anyone with major impurities. This is the meaning of the Aayah.

Uthaymeen seems to side with the latter opinion but states it is better to have Wudhoo and there is Ijmaa on this. No one should think that performing Tawaaf with and without Wudhoo is precisely the same thing.

A – If a woman is on her menses and she needs to perform an obligatory Tawaaf, then the majority say she is not allowed to enter the Masjid and must wait.

Others have stated that she may perform Tawaaf because of the necessity to do so.

For example, if she has to perform at-Tawaaf al-Ifaadah (which is a pillar of her Hajj and it won’t be accepted without it) and her travel group are going to leave before she becomes pure, in this case she may perform at-Tawaaf because of necessity. This is the opinion of Ibn Taymiyyah and Ibn al-Qayyim.

Others said she must pay the expiation and exit her Ihraam and perform her obligatory Hajj another time. Or she remains in Ihraam and travels with the group and comes back when she can to complete her Hajj – remaining in Ihraam throughout the whole time.

Uthaymeen states that this is the wrong opinion and entails a great deal of hardship also. However, the woman must remember that she is impure and not to let her impurity spread to the Masjid.

End of Chapter of Nullifiers. 
Next: Chapter of Ghusl.

Wednesday, March 02, 2016

Chapter: Nullifiers of Wudhoo - Praying Salaat (Part 12)

-Salaat is invalid without Wudhoo. ‘Uthaymeen explains that it is Haraam to pray without Wudhoo, based on the Quraan, the Sunnah and al-Ijmaa’.

As for proof from the Quraan:

Allaah, the Most High, Says:

“O you who believe! When you intend to offer As-Salat (the prayer), wash your faces and your hands (forearms) up to the elbows, rub (by passing wet hands over) your heads, and (wash) your feet up to ankles. If you are in a state of Janaba (i.e. had a sexual discharge), purify yourself (bathe your whole body)” [al-Maaidah 5:6]

The reason for washing here is made clear – for Salaat.
Based on this Aayaah, as Salaat is mentioned first, it has been made a condition for Salaat. So if a person is impure, major or minor forms, then, he must purify himself before he prays.
If he intends to pray purposely without Wudhoo in mockery of the religion, then he becomes a Kaafir.

If a person prays whilst he is impure on purpose but doesn’t intend to mock the religion then the scholars differed:

-The Hanafees are of the view that this person becomes a Kaafir thereby, because he is mocking the religion through his actions.
-The majority are of the view that he has committed a sin but he is not a Kaafir and mocking the religion is defined by his intentions and not his deeds.

Uthaymeen states the correct view is that it depends on his intention, if he intends to mock the religion then he apostates but if he doesn’t then he remains a Muslim as there is no evidence to take him out of Islaam.

As for proof from the Sunnah:

The Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him] said, “Allaah does not Accept Salaat of the impure one until he purifies himself.” [Reported by Muslim (224)]

And, “There is no Salaat except with purification.” [Reported by Ahmad (2/57); Aboo Dawood (59) and classed as Saheeh by Ibn Hajar in Fath (1410)]

And, “Allah does not Accept Salaat from any one of you who is impure until he performs Wudhoo.” [Reported by al-Bukhaaree (135) and Muslim (225)]

As for proof from al-Ijmaa’ (scholarly consensus which can’t be contradicted):

The Muslims are all in agreement that one cannot pray without Wudhoo.

Uthaymeen adds that as-Salaat is defined by actions of worship which start with Takbeer and end with Tasleem and has Rukoo’ and Sujood within them.

Others said it must be units of prayer. This definition was given by Ibn Taymiyyah (Majmoo’, 21/277) and Khateeb (Tahtheeb as-Sunnan, 1/52).

Uthaymeen says the first definition is more profound and precise.

Based on this definition of Salaat, is one allowed to do Sijdah for Quraan (at-Tilaawah) or Shukr without Wudhoo?

The Hanbalee Madhab are of the view that Sujood of Shukr and Tilaawah are types of prayer, so one must have Wudhoo, face the Qiblah and end it with Tasleem. It is also legislated that he says Takbeer when going down.

Uthaymeen states that the correct opinion is that these Sujood are not within the definition of Salaat, so the conditions of Salaat do not apply to them for the following reasons:

-The Prophet did these Sujoods and it is not narrated that he made the same prerequisites as Salaat for them. It is reported in Muslim that he did Sujood as-Shukr without Takbeer and Tasleem.

-The Prophet did Sujood for Tilaawah when Surah an-Najm was revealed and the Muslims and the Mushriks of Quraysh all did Sujood together. The Prophet didn’t specify Wudhoo here either.

Those who have the opposing view argue:

-Sijdah is a part of Salaat so if you are going to do it, you must have Wudhoo.

-The second proof used here was before Wudhoo was made obligatory for Salaat, thus cannot be used as proof.

In response we say:

There is explicit proof that the Prophet did Sujood without the conditions of Salaat being applied, thus the permissibility of doing Sujood for Shukr and Tilaawah without Wudhoo being established. This is also the opinion of Ibn Taymiyyah.
Further proof to suggest this is the fact that Ibn ‘Umar used to prostrate for Tilaawah without Wudhoo.

Undoubtedly, it is better to prostate with Wudhoo for Tilaawah, because it is always recommended to have Wudhoo when reciting the Quraan.

As for making it a condition for Sujood ash-Shukr then this is very weak, because this type of Sujood has been legislated when someone is blessed with a favour or averted from him harm. This is highly likely to happen to person when he is not pure. So if we were to say it is binding to have Wudhoo, we would be saying inadvertently, “Either go and make Wudhoo or don’t do Sujood at all.”


Thursday, February 25, 2016

Chapter: Nullifiers of Wudhoo - Touching the Mushaf (Part 11)

-It is not permissible for the one who is impure to touch the Mushaf (Quraan). Uthaymeen explains that this is the ruling irrespective if one is touching the Mushaf as a book or even if it’s just one Aayah – it is not permissible to touch it except with Wudhoo.

This is the opinion of the majority, except the Dhaahirees who permitted touching the Mushaf without necessitating Wudhoo.

The arguments presented from both sides include the following:

1-“This is indeed an honourable recital (the Noble Qur'an). In a Book well-guarded (i.e. Al-Lauh Al-Mahfuz), a Book that none can touch except the purified. A Revelation from the Lord of the 'Alamin (all of creation).” [al-Waaqi’ah 56:77-80]

The point of evidence here is the statement, “none can touch” and the words “the purified” (مُطَهَّرُ) refers to the one who has purified himself with Wudhoo or Ghusl.
The Dhaarihees argued that the word the “purified” (مُطَهَّرُ) refers to the Angels and not to humans, because humans are those who purify themselves (مطهِر).

The Dhaahirees said that the negation in this Aayah “none can touch” (لا يمس) refers to a negation of impossibility (النافية) not a negation of prohibition (الناهية), because the word “touch” is connected to negation as an accusative case with a Fatha (َ) and not a Dammah (ُ). So the meaning of the Aayah refers to the Book that is with Allaah known as the Lawh al-Mahfoodh and not the Mushaf – thus meaning that “none is able to touch it”, not “none is allowed to touch it”. To support this, there is a similar description given to the Lawh al-Mahfoodh in Surah ‘Abasa (see: 80: 11-16)

In response we say that this is information (خبر) but in the form of request (طلب), just like the Prophet saying, “There is no trade if a Muslim undercuts another.” The accusative case (منصوب) here is used (لا بيعَ) to mean a prohibition and not negation.

The Dhaahirees reject this argument because they argue that this linguistic principle - grammatically using information (خبر) in the form of request (طلب) - needs to be applied with evidence and here we have none. In fact the opposite can be argued if we combine the Tafseer of Surah al-Waaqi’ah and Surah ‘Abasa.

2-The Hadeeth of ‘Amr bin Hazm [may Allaah be Pleased with him] that the Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him] wrote a letter to the people of Yemen and within he wrote, “None is allowed to touch the Quraan except if he is pure.” [Reported by at-Tabaraanee (13217), al-Daaraqutnee (1/121) and al-Bayhaqee (1/88)]

The word “pure” (طاهر) refers to both major and minor forms of impurity.

The Dhaahirees argued that this Hadeeth is weak. Even if we use this Hadeeth, then the meaning is to prevent the Kuffaar from touching and respecting the book.
In response we say that this letter was written to Muslims, and the impurity here is not talking about the metaphorical form of impurity, rather it is talking about being free from physical forms of major and minor impurities.

3-By analogy – there is no speech better than the Speech of Allaah. So if purity is a condition for Tawaaf around His House, then purity in order to the touch His Speech is even more relevant.

The Dhaahirees rejected this as they reject Qiyaas and added that there still remains no specific evidence on this issue, so if there is no evidence then there is no ruling (حُكم).

Uthaymeen concludes by stating that the argument for the Dhaahirees about the Aayah in Surah al-Waaqi’ah is a strong one in which they are correct in.

Although, the Hadeeth of ‘Amr bin Hazm maybe weak, the scholars from the time of the Salaf up until now have used this as proof. So to argue that this narration is baseless then this is far from the truth.

Also, there are many who have said that the narration is acceptable because of its various routes including; Ishaaq bin Raahooyah, ash-Shafi’ee, Ibn ‘Abdul-Barr, Ibn Hajar and was used as proof by Imaam Ahmad. [see: at-Talkhees al-Habeer (175)]  

Also, Allaah Says:

“Allah does not want to place you in difficulty, but He wants to purify you” [al-Maa’idah 5:6]

This shows that the believer can have major and minor forms of impurity, and had the letter to the people of Yemen been to the Kuffaar then this would have been stated.
So the correct opinion is of the majority – it is not permitted to touch the Mushaf except for one who is pure in both major and minor forms.

A – This ruling includes both major and minor forms of impurity, as the word impurity (حدث) in the Sharee’ah refers to a situation in which prevents a person to pray Salaat, thus including both major and minor forms.

B – The whole of the Mushaf is included in the ruling here. Some of the Shafi’ees stated that one is allowed to touch the paper or the cover as this doesn’t have the Aayaat of Allaah on it. However the correct opinion is that one is not allowed to touch the whole book, including the covers and the surrounding papers because the Prophet said, “None should touch the Quraan except if he is pure.” Meaning, the book as a whole.

C – The Hanbalees stated that it is permitted for children to touch the cover and the surrounding papers of the Mushaf and the ruling only applied to adults. However, if the child wants to touch Aayaat then his guardian must make him do Wudhoo beforehand. The Shafi’ees stated that it is permitted for a child to hold the whole Mushaf, including its Aayat as he is at an age of not being accountable. Uthaymeen leaned towards this opinion but stated that the guardian for the child should teach and make the child do Wudhoo if it is possible beforehand.

D – The Hanbalees permitted children touching pieces of paper which have Aayaat written on them. They argue that this is not the actual Mushaf so it doesn’t carry the same ruling. Also, by making them do Wudhoo in this situation, it would create a great deal of difficulty. This is especially the case when trying to learn.

The majority have stated that it is not permitted to touch pieces of paper (or any other instrument) that have Ayaat of the Quraan written on them unless they are in a state of purity. However, they permitted one to write Aayaat on a piece of paper (or any other instrument) without Wudhoo because writing is not the same as touching.

Uthaymeen states that what is not permitted is to touch the Mushaf without Wudhoo, as for touching anything else which has Aayaat on it, and then this doesn’t require Wudhoo.
E - Touching books of Tafseer don’t require Wudhoo because this is not the Mushaf. Although the whole of the Quraan may be written within it, because what is not part of the Quraan is greater in volume. The evidence for this is that the Prophet used to send letters to the rulers who were non-Muslim and in them he would write Aayaat of the Quraan, however the speech of man had a greater proportion in these letters – thus he didn’t command that these letters be treated in the same way as Mushaf’s.

However, if the Mushaf is greater than the Tafseer or one is not is able to decipher which one is greater, then he must be pure before touching the Mushaf.


Wednesday, February 24, 2016

Chapter: Nullifiers of Wudhoo - Purification and a Nullifier but He Doesn't Know Which Came First (Part 10)

-If a person is certain that he has nullified his Wudhoo and he is also certain that he has purified himself, but is uncertain which one came first then he acts upon what is most likely.
Uthaymeen explains; a person say I know I broke my Wudhoo but I also know that I performed Wudhoo but I’m not sure which I did first, then we follow what is most likely and not to nullify the Wudhoo based on doubts.

For example, a person prays Fajr and stays awake until mid-morning and now wants to pray Salaat ad-Duhaa. He is certain he performed Wudhoo at Fajr but is also certain that he has broken his Wudhoo. We say to this person, your Wudhoo is broken, because the likelihood of you breaking Wudhoo is stronger and came after when you were certain you performed Wudhoo.

Another example, a person performs Wudhoo and prays Fajr and after that he is certain that he broke his Wudhoo but then performed Wudoo, but is not sure which one he did first; Wudhoo and then broke the Wudhoo or he broke the Wudhoo and then he performed the Wudhoo. In this instance we say you still have Wudhoo.

The principle here is if a person is certain that he has done something but then doubts whether that thing has been nullified or not, then in origin, the action he did that he was certain upon still remains and is not nullified.
So in the first example, the person was certain that he broke his Wudhoo and in the second example the person was certain that he re-preformed his Wudhoo.

A-     Some scholars (the Maalikees) have stated that if a person doubts (irrespective of which one came first) then it is obligatory for him to perform Wudhoo always, as the uncertainty needs to be removed.

The Hanbalees said if there is a doubt about which one came first then he must perform Wudhoo. 
Uthaymeen explains that the reason why the Hanbalees held this opinion is because we have two contradictory situations and the person doesn’t know which one to choose.

In the situation where we have two conflicting situations and there is no way one can decipher; then the correct opinion is to do what is on the safer side and perform Wudhoo, this way he will be certain to have Wudhoo once performing it

To conclude this point has four scenarios:

-He is certain that he has Wudhoo but thinks he may have nullified it. He doesn’t pay attention to the doubt and he has Wudhoo.

-He is certain that he is impure but thinks he may have performed Wudhoo. He doesn’t listen to the doubt and performs Wudhoo.

- He is certain he had Wudhoo and is certain that he broke it, but he knows which one came first. He follows what he knows in this situation.

-He is certain he had Wudhoo and is certain that he broke it, but doesn’t know which one came first. The safer opinion here is to repeat the Wudhoo.

Tuesday, February 23, 2016

Chapter: Nullifiers of Wudhoo - Doubts in Purification (Part 9)

-If a person doubts he has Wudhoo then he must go with what he is certain upon or what is most likely. Uthaymeen explains that if a person is certain that he is pure but has a doubt whether the Wudhoo has been broken, then the principle here is that his Wudhoo remains and no attention is paid to the doubt.

The evidence for this principle is the Hadeeth of Aboo Hurayrah [may Allaah be Pleased with him] that a man came complaining to the Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him] about doubts that he has about passing wind so he said, “Do no pay attention to your doubts unless you hear a sound or smell a smell.” In another narration he said, “Nothing has come out of you unless you hear…”

The Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him] also said, “If anyone of you doubts about his Salaat, then cast aside the doubt and act upon what he is certain upon.” [Reported by Muslim (571)]

A-The same applies to Ghusl. So if a person wakes up and finds himself wet yet he knows he didn’t have an erotic dream but now he is not sure if it is semen or not, then there is no Ghusl for him as he is certain that he didn’t have an erotic dream.

B-The opposite is also true – if a person is certain or thinks very likely that he doesn’t have Wudhoo but has an inkling that he has Wudhoo, then in origin he has no Wudhoo as this is what he is certain or most likely upon.

NOTE: this point is known as Qiyaas al-Aks (opposite analogy) which some scholars denied. The proof for this principle is the Hadeeth of Aboo Hurayah above and also the Hadeeth in which the Prophet described the relations one has with his wife a being a Sadaqah to which the Companions were surprised and then the Prophet said, “Do you not see if you were to have relations with other than your wife you would be sinful?...Likewise, having relations which with what is Halaal for you has a reward.”  [Reported by Muslim (1006)]

So this principle is extremely important and there are many issues which have been built upon it in issues of Fiqh.
Likewise, it solves several problems faced by many people – they have doubts in purity, in their Salaat, in matters of Talaaq, contracts etc.

If a person pays attention to this principle in his life, then the doors for Waswasa and doubts will be closed due to the blessings of the statements and wisdom that the Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him] came with.
Additionally, this principle illustrates the compassion found in al-Islaam; it wishes to remove stress, worry and doubt from mankind. Moreover, it wants mankind to act upon what is clear and apparent. So if a person uses this principle as a standard in his life then you will find this person being upright, because the Shaytaan wishes to create anxiety, fear and doubts through his Waswas. Shaytaan doesn’t stop in matters of purification either, this is what he often starts with and then moves on to as-Salaat, as-Siyaam and so on, until his whole life is based on doubts and conjecture.


So the Legislator (i.e. Allaah) has closed all paths that lead to Waswas and has eradicated it from its very origins by Commanding us not to pay attention to doubts lest it affects the make-up of a person.

Wednesday, February 10, 2016

Chapter: Nullifiers of Wudhoo - The Waajib Ghusl Replaces Wudhoo (Part 8)

8 – Everything that obligates Ghusl nullifies the Wudhoo. Uthaymeen explains that this in fact is not a nullifier but a principle.

That which obligates Ghusl are (major impurities) as follows:

                -Ejaculation
-Meeting of private parts
-Menses/Nifaas (postmortem bleeding)

-Uthaymeen adds that if a person makes Ghusl from any one of these major impurities, then it suffices as lifting the minor impurity as well and he doesn’t need to make a specific Wudhoo thereafter. This is because Allaah, the Most High, Says:

“If you are in a state of Janaba (i.e. major impurity), purify yourself (bathe your whole body)” [al-Maa’idah 5:6]

Allaah has Commanded that we take a bath and didn’t command us to make Wudhoo from afresh, despite it being in the same Aayah. The command to make Wudhoo was accompanied with minor forms of impurity.

So the correct opinion is that if a person is under major impurity and he has the intention to purify himself then this suffices for major and minor forms of impurity and he doesn’t need to make a separate Wudhoo.

-The Hanbalees say this rule only applies to the deceased. So if a person dies and then we have been commanded to make Ghusl for him and making Wudhoo is not essential, rather it is recommended. This is because Ghusl is to clean and Wudhoo is to lift spiritual impurity.

Uthaymeen objects to this opinion with the following:

-It is Waajib to make Wudhoo upon the deceased before giving him Ghusl for burial because the Prophet said, “Start washing him from his right side and the places of Wudhoo.” [Reported by al-Bukhaaree (1254) and Muslim (939)]. So there both are obligatory in this case.

-To make a distinction between Ghusl as a cleanser and Wudhoo as a purifier is incorrect because making Ghusl in the Aayah is described as being a cleanser and a purifier. Thus there is no difference.

-Even if we were to opine that making Wudhoo for the deceased is not Waajib, then making Ghusl which is stronger than making Wudhoo also covers the body parts for Wudhoo, thus taking its ruling.

Tuesday, February 09, 2016

Chapter: Nullifiers of Wudhoo - Camel Meat (Part 7)

7 – Eating camel meat nullifies the Wudhoo. Uthaymeen explains that this is the view with the Hanbalees and not the majority. This is another Mufradaat of Imaam Ahmad. Uthaymeen states that the correct opinion is that Wudhoo is nullified by eating camel meat.
The evidences for the Hanbalees:

-Hadeeth Jaabir bin Samarah [may Allaah be Pleased with him] that the Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him] was asked about making Wudhoo after eating camel meat and he replied, "Yes." He was then asked about goat's meat and he said, "If you want." [Reported by Muslim (360)]

-Hadeeth Al-Baraa' bin 'Aazib [may Allaah be Pleased with him] that the Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him] commanded, "Make Wudhoo after eating camel's meat."

-It is narrated on the authority of Usayd bin Hudayr [may Allaah be Pleased with him] that the Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him] performed Wudhoo after drinking camel milk. [Reported by Ahmad (3/352), Ibn Maajah (496), at-Tabaraanee (559-560)]

The evidences for the majority:

-Hadeeth Jaabir [may Allaah be Pleased with him] that the Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him] left making Wudhoo with whatever has been cooked over fire towards the end of his life (i.e. he used to make Wudhoo after eating something that had been cooked over fire in the beginning of Islaam). [Reported by Aboo Dawood (192), an-Nasaa'ee (185), Ibn Hibbaan (1134)]

They argued here that the Prophet stopped making Wudhoo for all forms of meat.

NOTE: when the texts mention a difference between the beginning of Islaam and towards the end of the life of the Prophet, then we always give precedence to what came after.

-Hadeeth Ibn 'Abbaas [may Allaah be Pleased with him] that the Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him], "Wudhoo is for whatever comes and not what goes in." [ash-Shafi'ee said this narration is weak and so did Ibn Hajar in al-Talkhees (155)]

The answer from the Hanbalees on these two points mentioned by the majority:

-As for the Prophet leaving what has been cooked over fire, this doesn’t negate the fact the ruling connected to camel meat, as camel meat is specific. So there is no abrogation here. Rather, the Hadeeth mentioned by the majority is general but the Hadeeth of camel meat is specific, thus given precedence in this issue.

-The evidences used by the majority is understood to mean it is recommended (Mustahab) whereas the view of the Hanbalees is that it is Waajib, again because there is a difference between general evidences and specific ones.

-The commands of the Prophet must be implemented unless we have weighty and specific evidence.

-Some said, like ash-Shawkaanee, that if the Prophet said something (command of Wudhoo after camel meat) but did something else (not performing Wudhoo with cooked food), then we give precedence to his statement over his action. Others said this principle is weak because everything he said and did is included in the Sunnah, thus we can't use this as a point against them.

-The narration they quote of Ibn Abbaas is weak (because Ibn al-Munkadir didn’t hear from Jaabir, and the presence of 'Abdallah bin Muhammad bin 'Aqeel who is weak "Layyin" and a "Mukhalat".), thus not being proof. There is a chain going back to Ibn Abbaas which is authentic but the correct opinion here is that it is a statement of Ibn Abbaas and not a Hadeeth from the Prophet (reported by al-Bayhaqee (1/116) and classed as Saheeh in Fath al-Baaree (1934)).

There are many sub-issues connected to camel meat:

A-There is no difference between raw and cooked camel meat, all of if nullifies the Wudhoo.

B-If a person doesn’t eat but uses camel meat for whatever else, this doesn't nullify the Wudhoo because it is only eating that is a nullifier.

C-There is no analogy between camel meat and other animals, even if the animal is Haraam there is no proof that it nullifies Wudhoo.

D-There is no difference between a little amount of consumption and a lot.

E-It must be camel meat, as for any other part of the camel, then this doesn’t nullify the Wudhoo, such as liver or milk.

Uthaymeen states that the correct view is that all parts of the camel (meat and organs) nullify Wudhoo. This is because:

-Meat in the Arabic language is generally referred to the whole animal such as the meat of pigs, refers to the whole pig: "Forbidden to you (for food) are:…the flesh of swine" [5:3].

-The Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him] would have explained if there was a difference between its meat and other parts of the body.

-The Sharee'ah doesn’t classify parts of the animal as being partly-Halaal or partly-Haraam, likewise the camel can't be partly a nullifier and partly not.

-The wording of it being a nullifier is taken in its generality and the evidence of camel milk has proceeded above.

As for milk then it is Mustahab for two reasons:

-The Ahadeeth that talk about nullification of Wudhoo are in reference to the meat and not milk. As for the Hadeeths of the Prophet making Wudhoo again after drinking camel milk then some of them are authentic and others aren’t.

-It is narrated that Anas [may Allaah be Pleased with him] said that the Prophet told the people of ‘Uranah (a tribe that came to the Prophet complaining of a particular disease) to drink the camel’s milk and urine as a cure. This incident tells us that it is not obligatory to make Wudhoo after drinking camel’s milk as the Prophet didn’t instruct them to do so.

For these two reasons it is Mustahab to perform Wudhoo after drinking camel’s milk.

F-Soup or gravy that has been made out of camel meat also nullifies the Wudhoo - by making analogy with swine – it not being permissible to eat stock made from pig.

            -Others said it isn’t a nullifier because one is physically eating camel meat.

Uthaymeen said the first opinion is stronger and safer. However, if one is unsure or the meat has completely disappeared then this doesn’t require Wudhoo.


Thursday, February 04, 2016

Chapter: Nullifiers of Wudhoo - Washing the Deceased (Part 6)

6 – Washing the deceased. Uthaymeen explains the linguistic differences between:

-Ghasl (غَسل): this is the name given to the action of washing or bathing (noun).

-Ghusl (غُسل): this is the action of washing or bathing (verb).
 So here, washing the deceased is a nullifier of Wudhoo.

-The opinion of the Hanbalees is that this nullifies the Wudhoo, this is irrespective of age or gender, or whether one physically touches the deceased or washes them from behind a barrier. The majority of the scholars (Hanafees, Shafi'ees and Maalikees) state that it is not a nullifier of Wudhoo.

-The Hanbalees state that that there is no difference between washing (غسل) and touching (مس), as long as one washes even if he doesn’t physically touch the deceased, his Wudhoo is broken.

Benefit in terminologies: opinions that Imaam Ahmad held which disagreed with the majority are often referred to as Mufradaat Madhab Ahmad.

-The evidences for the Hanbalees:

-The Hadeeth of Ibn 'Abbaas, Ibn 'Umar and Aboo Hurayah [may Allaah be Pleased with them all] [reported by 'Abdur-Razzaaq in his Musannaf (6101), Ibn Abee Shaybah in his Musannaf (11134) and al-Bayhaqee (305-306)] that washing the deceased nullifies the Wudhoo.

-Washing the deceased often involves touching impurities and the private parts.

The evidences for the majority:

-          There is no sound evidence to support Wudhoo being nullified by washing the deceased.

-          As for the narrations of the Companions mentioned, then even if we take this as a source of legislation the maximum we can say is that it is recommended to perform Wudhoo again and not Waajib.


Uthaymeen supports the view of the majority.

Wednesday, February 03, 2016

Chapter: Nullifiers of Wudhoo - Touching Ones Spouse (Part 5)

5 -  Touching ones spouse with desires. Uthaymeen explains that this ruling has several sub-issues:

                A - The age of the spouses is irrelevant. This is the correct opinion with Uthaymeen.
                            
    - Some stated that the minimum age of the spouse has to be seven years old.

- Others said the ages must be similar. So if a person of a particular age is able to have relations with another of a similar age, then the Wudhoo is broken via touching with desires. For example, if a seventeen year old touches his wife who is younger than him with desires, then the Wudhoo is not broken because he is not able to have relations with here, even if he touches her with desires.

B – The correct opinion with Uthaymeen is that the touching women even with desires doesn’t nullify the Wudhoo.
-Others (the Shafi’ees’) were of the opinion that all forms of touching women invalidates Wudhoo, whether it be with desires or not. This is whether it be his wife or any other female. From their proofs are the following:

- “or you have been in contact with women” [al-Maa’idah 5:6]. Touching (مس) is general, so it can be with the hand or other than the hand, touching women nullifies the Wudhoo.

-Others (the Hanbalees and Malikees) stated all touching with desires nullifies the Wudhoo. From their proofs are the following:

- They used the Aayah quoted above and stated that the word “contact” is specified by the Hadeeth in which A’aishah [may Allaah be Pleased with her and her father] that described the Prophet [Peace and Blessings of Allaah be upon him] praying and in front of him were her outstretched feet. Every time he wanted to prostrate, he would touch her so that she may move her feet. This shows that the Prophet prayed after touching women.

- Had merely touching women, even without desires, had been a nullifier then this would create a great deal of hardship for the Ummah.

-Others (the Hanafees and Ibn Taymiyyah) were of the opinion that touching women never nullifies Wudhoo, even with desires. From their evidences include the following:

                - The fact that the Prophet touched A’aishah whilst praying.

- There is no explicit proof to claim that the Wudhoo is nullified by touching, either with or without desires.

- Purification and nullification is only based on clear evidences.

- The Ayah quoted above was explained by Ibn ‘Abbaas [may Allaah be Pleased with him and his father] and others, to mean intercourse.

- The Ayah itself is talking about major impurity, giving examples of going to the bathroom as minor forms of impurity and marital relations as a major form of impurity. If we interpret “contact” as touching with the hand then this would mean that the Ayah talks about minor impurities without mentioning major impurities despite stating, “If you are in a state of Janaba (i.e. had a sexual discharge), purify yourself (bathe your whole body)” [5:6]. This kind of disorganization doesn’t befit the eloquence of the Quraan.

C - The part of the body is also irrelevant, as long as one has desires the Wudhoo is nullified via touching. But the correct opinion with Uthaymeen is that all forms of touching do not nullify the Wudhoo – whether one touches a body part (including hair and nails) or something that is not physically part of her like her clothes.

D - The Hanbalees stated that ruling applies to the sane and insane. But the correct opinion with Uthaymeen is that all forms of touching do not nullify the Wudhoo.

E – Uthaymeen states the ruling only applied to men and not women, with the majority.

-The Hanbalees were of the view that it applies to both genders because of Qiyaas Jalee (clear analogy) – if the rulings apply to one gender then it applies to the other.

F – Uthaymeen states that if a man touches another man or a woman touches another woman with desires, then the Wudhoo is broken. This is Qiyaas with those who stated that touching with desires breaks the Wudhoo.

-          Others stated that it doesn’t break the Wudhoo even if the touching is with desires because inter-gender relations are not recognized in the Sharee’ah.

But the correct opinion as stated above is that touching with desires doesn’t nullify Wudhoo as there is no sufficient evidence to suggest it does.

G – Touching the rear exit. Uthaymeen states that touching the rear exit nullifies the Wudhoo, this is because of the Hadeeth of Aboo Hurayrah which was reported by Imaam Ahmad, “Whoever touches his private parts then he must perform Wudhoo.” The word “private part” here is general and applies to both the front and the rear.

Uthaymeen said the scholars differed on the rulings connected to the rear private parts just as they differed on the rulings connected to the front private parts (i.e. does it have to be skin to skin, with or without desires etc.)
Uthaymeen states that this applies to the actual exit and not surrounding organs.

Uthaymeen states that the correct opinion about touching the rear exit is the same as touching the front private parts – it doesn’t nullify the Wudhoo.


Thursday, January 28, 2016

Chapter: Nullifiers of Wudhoo - Touching the Private Parts (Part 4)

4 – Touching the private parts (TN: for whom we are allowed to touch the private parts of – i.e. oneself, spouse, one’s own children, washing the deceased through a barrier etc.) nullifies the Wudhoo. Uthaymeen explains that there is a difference of opinion on this issue:

-Some of the scholars stated that it must be skin for skin in order for the Wudhoo to be invalidated. This is because (مس) or touching cannot be affirmed through a barrier.

-Others stated it must be the palm that touches the private part. So if one touches his private part with his thigh or his elbow, then the Wudhoo is not invalidated. They use the Hadeeth, “If one touches his private parts without there being a barrier than the Wudhoo has become obligatory” [reported by Ahmad (2/333), Ibn Hibban (1118), ad-Daaraqutnee (1-147) and al-Bayhaqee (2-131) from Aboo Hurayrah]

-Others said it breaks Wudhoo in all cases (the Hanbalees). Their evidences are as follows:

- The Hadeeth of Busrah bint Safwaan, “Whoever touches his private parts then they must make Wudhoo.” [Aboo Dawood (181), at-Tirmidhee (82), an-Nasaa’ee (163) and Ibn Maajah (489)]

- The Hadeeth of Aboo Hurayrah, “If one of you touches his private parts with his hands, without a barrier, then they must perform Wudhoo” [Ibn Hibban (246)]

- By touching the private parts one may stir desire or extract something impure -thus carrying the same reasoning for sleep being a nullifier of Wudhoo.

-Others said that touching the private part doesn’t nullify the Wudhoo. Their evidences are as follows:

- The Hadeeth of Talq bin ‘Alee where the Prophet was asked about touching the private parts to which he replied, “It is merely a part of your body.” [Reported by Aboo Dawood (182), an-Nasaa’ee (165), at-Tirmidhee (85) and Ibn Maajah (483)]

- The origin of purification is that it remains except with proof that it has been nullified.

- There is a third opinion which states that Wudhoo is nullified if one touches his private parts if the touching is done with desire (the majority). If there is no desire, then the Wudhoo has not been nullified. This view reconciles all the evidences presented above, and this is what must be done so as to not neglect some Hadeeth whilst acting upon others. Additional proofs:

-The saying of the Prophet, “It is merely a part of your body” shows that touching any part of your body doesn’t nullify the Wudhoo, except if there is desire.

- As  for the argument that one may not know what exits if he touches his private part, then if we attach the ruling of touching to desires then this is more appropriate. Thus we are saying if you touch your private parts then the Wudhoo is not broken, but if it is coupled with desires then there is a chance that something has exited.

-Others from the scholars have stated that touching the private parts never invalidates the Wudhoo, even if desires are present, rather the Ahadeeth express a recommendation to repeat Wudhoo and not a nullifier of it. There evidences are as follows:

-You Hanbalees claim that touching women without desires doesn’t nullify the Wudhoo but here you are saying that touching your private parts with desires does nullify your Wudhoo. This seems to be a contradiction.

-The Hadeeth of Busrah is an obligation and the Hadeeth of Talq negates Wudhoo, so combining them together shows that the command has been lessened to mean recommended (Mustahab).

-The correct opinion is the opinion of the Hanafees and Ibn Taymiyyah, is that touching the private parts never invalidates the Wudhoo even if one touches it with desire. Rather, it is Mustahab to do Wudhoo again in all cases. His evidences:
                - The Ahaadeeth can be combined to this interpretation.

- The evidences which say we should perform Wudhoo again mean that it is better in order to be on the safe, not proving obligation or nullification of Wudhoo.

- The Hadeeth of Talq came before the Hadeeth of Busrah, and was acted on for a large period of time without there being any retraction.

- Also, the Hadeeth of Talq shows the reason for the ruling, so as long as the reason is described then the ruling must be connected to it.

- Some scholars stated that if two narrations or opinions of the Companions contradict each other, then sometimes we take the opinion of the one who came later as his opinion or narration is closer to when Islaam was completed. However this rule can’t always be applied in this way, because what this implies is that the first ruling has been abrogated by the latter, but as long as reconciliation is possible then this is a must.

Uthaymeen summarises this ruling:

-If a person touches his private parts then it is Mustahab for him to preform Wudhoo and it is not a nullifier of the Wudhoo. This is irrespective of whether he touched it with desire or without desire. Those who stipulate desire have a very strong reasoning also, so I say it is better to act upon this opinion.

-Uthaymeen adds that the ruling in this issue is connected to the private part and not the organs around it, so if one touches his private parts from the front or the back, then this is what is being discussed here.

-Uthaymeen also points out that genitals which have been amputated are not included in the ruling either.

-Uthaymeen also adds that the ruling doesn’t include hermaphrodites as they have no clear gender. So if one touches them from the front or the back, the Wudhoo is not invalidated.

-The Hanbalees stated that if one touches the genitals of a hermaphrodite with desire, then the Wudhoo is broken, but if it is touched without desire then the Wudhoo is correct.

-They also stated that if one touches both the front and the back of a hermaphrodite then the Wudhoo is also broken.


-The only exception is if one touches the private part of a hermaphrodite but they have two gender organs but one is dormant. If one touches the dormant one then the Wudhoo is not broken.